In Review: My Perfect Mistake (Over the Top #1) by Kelly Siskind

Posted July 27, 2016 by Kim in 5 Stars, In Review / 2 Comments

In Review: My Perfect Mistake (Over the Top #1) by Kelly SiskindMy Perfect Mistake by Kelly Siskind
Series: Over the Top #1
Genres: Adult, Contemporary, Romance
Publication date: April 5, 2016
Publisher: Forever Yours
Format: eARC, 340 pages
How I got it: NetGalley
Add it: Goodreads
Buy it: Amazon | Barnes & Noble | iTunes
My rating:

What happens in Aspen
is definitely not staying in Aspen. . .

A girls’ trip to Aspen was exactly what Shay needed to forget about her toxic ex-boyfriend. She’s got her girls, pristine slopes for skiing, and hot guys everywhere. Of course, her epic self-rediscovery goes completely to hell when a wild (and deliciously hot) skier knocks Shay on her ass . . . and war is declared.

Kolton doesn’t know what it is about Shay that makes him lose it. Not just his cool—although she does have an unholy gift for that—but his restraint. When anger gives way to explosive chemistry, they’re both shaken with the intensity of it. But somewhere between lust and hate, Kolton and Shay realize they could have something real . . . if they don’t kill each other first.


In Review My Thoughts

My Perfect Mistake is one of those books I saw floating around for quite awhile before I actually decided to read it. It was getting some great reviews from bloggers whose opinions I trust – and tend to agree with when it comes to most books – but I just didn’t make time to read it. Boy, I wish I hadn’t waited quite so long. It was fresh, funny and sexy as hell. I love discovering new-to-me authors!

I was sucked into My Perfect Mistake from the very first page. No lie. I liked Shay’s spunky, sassy attitude. She was getting over a long relationship (to a douche) but she didn’t let it get her down. Instead, she took the opportunity to find herself again… with the help of her friends and a trip to Aspen. To say she and Kolton didn’t exactly hit it off when the first met is a HUGE understatement. They pretty much loathed each other, yet there was a lingering attraction neither could deny. (Have I mentioned I love a good antagonistic romance?) As much as I liked Shay and connected with her, I felt the same about Kolton. I do love my grumpy heroes. (And the single dad storyline?! Melted. All over the place.) I loved the passion and the intensity these two had when they were in the same room. They just clicked. Their banter was awesome. I found them super easy to root for, despite the challenges anything between them would bring.

Characters make or break a book (and series) for me. It’s been awhile since I connected with an entire group of characters as quickly and as hard as I did with the ones in My Perfect Mistake. I already said how much I loved Shay and Kolton, but they’re just the beginning. Kolton’s son, Jackson, was adorable. I loved him and the interactions with him and Kolton and Shay. One of my favorite things about a standalone series like this is the opportunity to get to know the characters who will star in later books in advance of their story being told. I enjoy how it allows me to connect with them. This definitely happened with Lily and Sawyer and Raven and Nico. I enjoy this group of friends so very much. They each bring something unique and special to this series. I enjoy the friendships nearly as much as the romance.

Did someone say total package? Because that’s exactly what this book was for me. Anytime you can give me friendship, romance and sexy times with a dose of feels, you can consider me sold. Even better when it comes from a new-to-me author, someone who I can eagerly follow going forward (and whose backlist I can devour).

The one good thing about waiting so long to read the first book is that I could jump right into the second, A Fine Mess. Sure, it follows a different couple (Lily and Sawyer, FTW!!) but it’s the same world – one that I’m borderline obsessed with. I love Kelly’s writing. I adore her characters and the romances and friendships. The wait for the third book is going to suck, but I’m pretty sure it’ll be worth it. After reading about Nico and Raven for two books now, I’m already shipping the hell out of them. But, I digress. If you love romance and you’re looking for a fresh voice, you should check out this book. (And the following ones, of course.)

I received a copy of this book from the publisher, via NetGalley, exchange for an honest review.


For five years, I put him first. His wants. His needs. I wasn’t even second. A distant third, maybe. 

I’m done with meaningless. I’m just not sure my dick got the memo.

I’ve had good sex before. Great sex. But I’ve never experienced the kind of desperation she inspires, the heat that drives our frenzied hands and mouths—raw and rough and spontaneous in the trees, the snow, or a bathroom.

Most of the time, I can’t decide if I want to throttle Shay or fuck her, but there’s a pull between us, an elastic force that’s got me hooked. In three days.

Is his heart beating as fast as mine? Has he turned into a sparkler, too?

“I want you in my bed. I want you under me, over me, next to me. I want you like I’ve never wanted anyone.” 


About Kelly Siskind

A small-town girl at heart, Kelly moved from the city to open a cheese shop with her husband in northern Ontario. When she’s not neck deep in cheese or out hiking, you can find her, notepad in hand, scribbling down one of the many plot bunnies bouncing around in her head. She laughs at her own jokes and has been known to eat her feelings—Gummy bears heal all. She’s also an incurable romantic, devouring romance novels into the wee hours of the morning.


Let's Chat

Have you read My Perfect Mistake?
What’d you think?


Tags: , , , ,


Leave a Reply

2 responses to “In Review: My Perfect Mistake (Over the Top #1) by Kelly Siskind

  1. Omg this sounds so good! Total package? Hell yeah! I requested A Fine Mess since Nick loved it so obviously I need to read it. I actually didn’t know it was part of a series and now that I know I’m eager to start it from the beginning! Great review 🙂